Do I Like Him? Sorting Through Mixed Feelings

Updated December 12, 2024by Regain Editorial Team

Sometimes, when we notice a new person we'd perhaps like to get to know, we don't necessarily have only positive thoughts. Our feelings about him may be mixed. It isn't always easy sorting out the feelings you have about someone. There could be a whole host of things that are drawing you to him. Not all of these things may be particularly helpful or healthy, resulting in mixed feelings and wondering, "Do I like him, or is it something else?". You may need to sort through all of these mixed feelings to determine whether or not you really like this new person of interest and want to pursue him.

Here are some ways to figure it all out.

Do I like him? Identify your emotional state

Not sure about your feelings?

Before you can know whether or not you like someone else, it helps to know yourself. You have to know what you like before you can know who you like. You also need to think about your values and consider what matters most in your life. It may even serve you well to objectively contemplate the way in which you've been behaving recently. Are you in a good place for a new relationship? 

Reflecting on your relationship readiness

Once you've taken stock of who you are, where you are, and what you want out of any potential relationship, you can begin to sort through all the feelings you're having about this new person you're considering getting to know better. 

Do I like him? Think about how well you know him

After you dig into your mixed feelings, take a moment to think about how well you really know him. Is he someone you've talked to and gotten to know over time? Have you just seen him around but have never actually interacted with him? Did you see his profile on a dating app and liked what you saw? If you've spotted him online, how much of a chance is there that you will ever even see him in person? Are your emotions about him as a person so intense that you can't imagine not going on a date with him? 

Identify your emotions

The less you know about him, the less likely it is that your feelings are from real affection. Although you may feel like you like him, it might be worth knowing more about him before you pursue a relationship. After all, falling in love should be predicated on more than just base feelings and instincts such as physical attraction. Consider exactly what it is you're feeling and think about the specific reasons you're attracted to him.

Writing in a journal can help

If the question of what it is you're feeling seems too hard to answer, take some time to write about your mixed emotions in a journal. Write down something that makes you unique and different from other people you know. Write about the things that make you happy or sad. Write about these mixed feelings you have towards this person who's caught your eye. Make a list of the strengths and weaknesses you see in yourself. Get a deep sense of who you are as a person before you go looking for someone else; failure to do so may be the reason for your mixed feelings.

Consider your goals when you write, as it is important to understand your future plans so that you can eventually picture a future that includes a new relationship without any mixed feelings. Your journal should be a safe haven in which you can feel natural and properly express your true feelings—even if they are mixed—and values in an organized fashion.

Evaluating your attraction to him

Make a list

If you don't know him very well, you might be falling in love with the idea of him rather than who he actually is. It's quite common to dream about an ideal mate. People develop a sort of list of characteristics and qualities they want in their ideal partner. These could be physical attributes or other characteristics you can notice right away.

However, those ideals are just a starting point. You might be drawn to him because he seems to fit your mold for the perfect person to be with. Yet, until you know him better, your emotions towards him are mixed. So, don't be afraid to ask yourself, "Do I like him or the idea of him?"

Think about how your past emotional relationships turned out

If you've had romantic relationships before, think about how they went. What were the successful parts? What were the not-so-successful parts? Ask yourself if you're interested in the current guy or if you're trying to replace an ex you were once with, as that could be the cause of your mixed feelings. 

You might like him because something about him is similar to a guy you used to be in a relationship with. Or it might be that you're rushing into liking the new guy because he seems so different from your ex. Either way, this may lead to trouble because you aren't seeing him for who he is on his own merits, and this could be a contributing factor to your mixed feelings.

The influence of external factors

Consider whether friends are influencing your emotions

Your friends' opinions can have a strong influence on you, especially if you're already experiencing mixed feelings towards someone. If they think you should get together with a guy, they may push you into thinking you like him instead of accepting your mixed feelings. They might talk about how great he is or even try to convince you to ask him for a date. Conversely, they may tell you they don't think this is the right guy for you for one reason or another. 

They may have the best of intentions, but your friends' choices aren't necessarily the ones you would make for yourself. Your feelings—mixed and not—are real, and they should not be manipulated by the opinions of others.

Ask yourself if you're comfortable being yourself around him

Not sure about your feelings?

Maybe you've met this guy and have been around him at least a few times. If so, think about how you felt when you were around him. Maybe you worried that your clothes weren't stylish or your hair was not at its best. Perhaps you were afraid to say what you wanted to say because you were afraid he would like you less if he knew what you were like inside. How comfortable you are around him can play a big part in your mixed feelings towards him.

Unless you feel comfortable when you're with him, any relationship you might have with him may be awkward. For a relationship to develop and thrive, each person in the relationship must act and feel natural when spending time with the other, which will help a bond form between them despite initial mixed feelings.

Exploring professional support

An online therapist can help you sort out mixed feelings

If someone new has piqued your interest, but you're not entirely sure if he's right for you, this can bring on some mixed feelings. You will need to sort through these feelings to determine if this is a person you want to pursue or not.

Regain counselors can offer an impartial, non-judgmental, and empathetic ear. You can be matched with a therapist who is trained in working with individuals with your particular issue. Regain counselors are flexible, and they can meet with you via in-app texting, phone chat, or video session. You can meet at a time that works best for your schedule, and you don't need to travel to an office. Your sessions can take place in the comfort of your own home.

Online therapy has become a popular way to work through issues and learn more about yourself. No matter where you live, you can connect with an online therapist. Many individuals have found online therapy as effective as in-person therapy for helping with relationship issues.

In therapy, you can sort out your mixed feelings about your person of interest. You can also develop a better sense of what you're looking for in a guy in general. Your counselor might teach you relationship skills, as well, and help you understand how your decisions about who to bring into your orbit could affect your life. Once you know more about your true feelings for him, you can decide what to do next.

Mixed feelings? Try BetterHelp today.

For Additional Help & Support With Your ConcernsThis website is owned and operated by BetterHelp, who receives all fees associated with the platform.
The information on this page is not intended to be a substitution for diagnosis, treatment, or informed professional advice. You should not take any action or avoid taking any action without consulting with a qualified mental health professional. For more information, please read our terms of use.
Get the support you need from one of our therapistsGet Started
This website is owned and operated by BetterHelp, who receives all fees associated with the platform.